• 0 Posts
  • 454 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 9th, 2023

help-circle











  • Perhaps I phrased it badly.

    No, not at all. My comment wasn’t dismissive of your post at all. I just was intrigued by the paradox of fashion and brutalism.

    If there was any critique in my comment is more directed at the source you quoted. It’s really forcing the Corbusier angle a bit too much, in my honest opinion. It’s late brutalism, with a bit too much beatification going on to be true to the style.

    I do like the building a lot and it’s intriguing to see the headway they made with concrete casting to archieve the rounder shapes.


  • “let’s use concrete only because it’s the fashion”

    This is a paradoxical sentence in this context. Raw material was used because it was practical and functional, but at the same time it was fashionable too.

    It’s precisely what fashion is, a trend in design in a certain art school. However the lack of an aesthetic ideology does make it anti-fashion too.

    One could say that the embellishments that mellow out the raw/harshness of the brutalist style is antithetical to it, though. It’s think that Corbusier would take offense with his name associated with this.





  • Even earlier on people mused on this particular habit. In 1577 French essayist Étienne de la Boétie wrote his Discourse on voluntary servitude where he explored why people seemed to prefer an autocrat who robbed them over freedom.

    To him, the great mystery of politics was obedience to rulers. Why in the world do people agree to be looted and otherwise oppressed by government overlords?

    According to de la Boétie people prefer being a courtier to a decisive overlord over making their own choices, backseating and deferring responsibility rather than deciding for themselves.

    It’s dad sad that in 450 years that doesn’t seem to have changed.