• 0 Posts
  • 314 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: October 9th, 2023

help-circle

  • On the one hand she argues that it’s not true that she loves Russia, in fact one can’t even have emotions like love towards a country:

    It’s impossible to have a real personal emotional relationship with any nation … You’re not loving the actual country, you’re loving a small mental representation of it that you have constructed inside your head.

    On the other hand, her entire blog is aimed at provoking emotional reactions against the US, which she admits she hates:

    I hate what they love so they assume I must love what they hate.

    Are countries simply mental representations or are they valid objects of repulsion and hatred? It depends on the country, comrade! Russia exists only in your mind, so your feelings about Russia are invalid. But the US is an actual twisted abomination!















  • And how did you determine what the purpose of fruit is? It certainly can’t communicate its preferences or desires.

    All you can observe is that the species as a whole thrives when fruit is consumed. But the same is true of farm animals. You are simply projecting the motivations you want to see, like self-sacrifice, onto one but not the other. After all, many fruits are poisonous. That suggests that fruits don’t want to be eaten, but animals evolved mechanisms to safely eat some fruit.

    Finally, factory farms certainly cause animals to suffer but from an evolutionary perspective thriving is not about avoiding suffering. It’s about producing offspring, and in that sense farm animals thrive. And given that the OP is about the potential suffering of plants, I don’t see why fruit farms are any less horrific than animal farms.